The Economic cost of your hires: How to measure it

Author
Emilia Kruszewska
Former educator & EdTech Sales leader -> turned EdTech recruiter and talent strategist

Ask what a poor hire cost you and most people count the salary, or the agency fee. Both are real. Neither is the biggest part of the bill.

So here is the question: what does one poor hire actually cost your company, and could you put a defensible number on it this week?

Below is a way to do it: four cost lines, a worked example in pounds, and a method for scaling it up to a year. You can run the same sums in the Cost of EdTech Hiring Calculator, which uses the same four headings: salary, lost sales, management time and rehiring.

The four cost lines

1. Salary paid for output you did not get

Take the fully loaded monthly cost of the role: salary plus employer National Insurance, pension, benefits and, for sales roles, commission. Multiply it by the months the person was in post, then by the share of expected output they did not deliver. Ask the line manager for an honest estimate of that share. For a quota-carrying role, compare against quota.

2. Management time

Count the hours spent coaching, correcting, documenting and having the difficult conversations, plus the hours the exit itself takes: HR, handover, legal advice if needed. Multiply by an hourly value for that time, and use the same rate every time so your numbers can be compared.

3. Rehiring

Sometimes you pay for hiring twice. The first process is written off, and the second starts from zero. In a time-per-hire breakdown I wrote for EdTech hiring managers, one hire takes 25 to 35 hours of internal time across writing the job description, sifting 150 or more CVs, phone screens, interviews, coordination and closing the offer. At £100 an hour of internal value, the illustrative rate in that breakdown, that is £2,500 to £3,500 per process before any adverts or fees.

Then add the replacement's ramp. The Bridge Group's 2024 survey of 172 B2B SaaS companies put average account executive ramp at 5.7 months, and Oxford Economics found 24 to 28 weeks to full productivity in the sectors it studied. Until the replacement gets there, you are paying for someone who is not yet delivering full output.

4. Lost sales

This is the expected bookings from the territory or book of business, minus what was actually booked, across the months the role under-delivered and the weeks it sat empty. A vacancy saves the salary but still costs the output, so it belongs here and not in line 1.

It is the softest line, and the one a finance director will challenge first. Bookings are not profit, and some deals slip rather than vanish. So I keep it out of the headline total and show it beside it.

A worked example: a mid-level Account Executive who leaves after six months

Every figure below is an assumption. Replace each one with your own.

  • Base salary of £60,000 and employer on-costs of 20%. That gives £72,000 a year, or £6,000 a month.
  • They leave after six months, having delivered 40% of what a good hire would have in that time.
  • Each hiring process takes 30 hours of internal time at £100 an hour, the middle of the 25 to 35 hour range above.
  • A new hire ramps on a simple curve: 0% of full output in month one, then 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% from month five. The first four months therefore cost 2.5 months of full output (100% + 75% + 50% + 25% of a month).

The sums:

  • Salary: six months at £6,000 is £36,000. The 60% they did not deliver is £21,600.
  • Management time: two hours a week for 26 weeks, plus eight hours for the exit, is 60 hours. At £100 an hour, that is £6,000.
  • Rehiring: £3,000 for the first process, £3,000 for the second, and 2.5 months of ramp at £6,000, which is £15,000. Together, £21,000.
  • Total: £48,600, or 81% of base salary.

That is before any advert or agency spend, and before lost sales. Suppose the role carries a £360,000 annual quota, or £30,000 a month at full speed. On the same ramp curve, a good hire books about £105,000 in their first six months (3.5 months of output). If this hire delivered 40% of that, £63,000 of bookings were missed.

Change an assumption and see what happens. If they had delivered 60% instead of 40%, the total falls to £41,400. A generous reading still leaves a five-figure bill.

Turn one hire into an annual figure

One exit is a story. A rate is a number you can manage. Start with a question you can answer from HR records rather than memory: of the last ten people you hired, how many reached their first anniversary, or are on track to?

Then multiply early exits per year by the cost per exit. Say you make 12 hires a year and two do not reach their first anniversary. That is one in six. At £48,600 each, the annual cost is £97,200, before lost sales. It is worth asking whether you would tolerate that failure rate in any other process in your business.

How to present it to your finance director
  • Use your own payroll data, not a benchmark. Benchmarks are for sense-checking.
  • Show the hard costs (salary, management time, rehiring) first, with lost sales beside them rather than inside the total.
  • Give a low, central and high case. The share of output delivered is a judgement, so show how far it moves the answer.
  • State your assumptions on the page. A number with its workings survives challenge better than a bigger number without them.
What actually moves the number

Every line above starts when someone leaves early, so the biggest lever is fewer early exits. Three things are worth working on.

  • Test fit before the offer, not after month three. In the CareerBuilder survey, employers most often described a bad hire by the quality of their work (54%), a negative attitude (53%) and not working well with others (50%). And 35% said they had hired someone who lacked some of the skills but who, they thought, would learn quickly. None of that is visible on a CV. A structured conversation about expectations, and a short assessment of how someone is likely to work in your team, help you surface it before the offer rather than after.
  • Shorten the vacancy. Keeping warm talent pools, and seeing only people who already fit the role, cuts the hours in line 3 and the weeks of lost sales in line 4.
  • Shorten the ramp. Oxford Economics reported that people joining from the same sector reached full productivity in 15 weeks, against 32 weeks for people joining from another sector. That study was not about EdTech, and it dates from 2014, but the direction is plain: sector experience shortens the ramp.

A replacement guarantee is worth having, because it covers the second search. It does not return the pay or the ramp, which is why preventing the early exit is worth more than insuring against it.

Run your own numbers

Try the sums with your own figures in the Cost of EdTech Hiring Calculator. For a practical companion on EdTech hiring, download the EdTech hiring cheat sheet.

Sources