Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Hiring your first Customer Success Manager is a major step for an EdTech company.
A strong Customer Success Manager can improve onboarding, increase product use, protect renewals and turn customers into long term advocates.
The wrong hire may create a friendly layer between the company and its customers without solving the problems that lead to churn.
But poor retention doesn’t always mean you hired the wrong person.
Sometimes the product isn’t delivering enough value. Sometimes sales promised something the company can’t deliver. Sometimes one person has been given 150 customers and told to build meaningful relationships with all of them.
The person responsible for revenue needs to define what customer success owns, how it works with sales and how performance will be measured.
That person may be a CRO, Sales Director, VP Sales, Head of Revenue, Head of Customer Success or another commercial leader.
Your first Customer Success Manager shouldn’t be hired simply because the sales team is too busy to answer customer questions.
Customer success isn’t a more polished name for customer support.
Support usually responds when a customer has a problem or question.
Customer success works proactively to help customers achieve the outcomes they expected when they bought the product.
The role may include:
Before recruiting, the revenue leader should be able to answer:
You don’t need a perfect customer journey.
But the Customer Success Manager needs more than a list of customers and a request to keep everyone happy.
Customer success can report into different parts of a business.
The role may report to:
The reporting line should reflect what the person is expected to own.
When the role is heavily focused on renewals and expansion, reporting into a revenue leader may make sense.
When the role focuses mainly on implementation, adoption and customer outcomes, it may sit within a customer function.
Problems begin when the reporting line and the targets don’t match.
A Customer Success Manager shouldn’t be told that customer outcomes are the priority while being measured only on expansion revenue.
Equally, someone who owns renewals needs clear commercial targets and access to contract information.
Customer success titles are used for very different jobs.
One company may want someone to run training sessions and answer product questions.
Another may expect the person to manage senior stakeholders, forecast renewals and grow a multimillion pound portfolio.
A third may need an implementation specialist who can coordinate integrations, data and project plans.
Look at where customers are struggling.
When customers take too long to launch, you may need an Implementation Manager.
When they launch but don’t use the product well, you may need a Customer Success Manager focused on adoption.
When customers are seeing value but nobody owns renewals or expansion, you may need a commercially focused Customer Success Manager or Account Manager.
When the main issue is product problems and technical queries, you may need customer support.
Don’t combine four jobs simply because they all involve speaking to customers.
A strong Customer Success Manager needs more than warmth, patience and organisation.
They should be able to separate what the customer bought from what the customer is trying to achieve.
A school hasn’t bought a platform because it wants another login.
It may want to reduce teacher workload, improve pupil progress or create more consistent practice across several schools.
A university may want to improve student engagement, support retention or give staff better information.
The Customer Success Manager should keep conversations focused on those outcomes.
Onboarding should have clear milestones, owners and deadlines.
The Customer Success Manager may need to coordinate:
They need to keep progress moving without taking responsibility for work that belongs to other teams.
Logging into a product isn’t the same as using it successfully.
A good Customer Success Manager can identify which users are active, which features matter and where adoption has stalled.
They should be comfortable using product data alongside customer conversations.
Education purchases often involve users, senior leaders, finance, IT, procurement and data protection teams.
Different people may expect different outcomes.
The Customer Success Manager needs to build relationships beyond one enthusiastic contact.
When that contact leaves, the account shouldn’t collapse.
A customer meeting shouldn’t be a pleasant catch up followed by a list of product updates.
Strong Customer Success Managers prepare properly.
They bring relevant data, discuss progress, identify risks and agree clear actions.
Customers rarely decide to leave without warning.
Risk may appear through:
Strong Customer Success Managers notice these signs and raise them early.
Customer success isn’t about saying yes to every request.
The person needs to explain what is possible, challenge unrealistic expectations and avoid promising features or services that haven’t been agreed.
The Customer Success Manager doesn’t need to act like a new business salesperson.
But they should understand revenue.
They should know:
The Customer Success Manager should bring clear evidence to sales, product, support and leadership teams.
“The customer doesn’t like it” isn’t useful feedback.
Strong feedback explains:
Your first Customer Success Manager may need to create onboarding templates, customer plans, health scores, meeting structures and renewal processes.
They need to manage customers while helping the revenue leader build a more consistent way of working.
Education experience can be a major advantage.
Someone who understands schools, multi academy trusts, colleges or universities may already recognise:
They may also build trust with users more quickly because they understand the language and working environment.
But sector knowledge shouldn’t replace customer success skills.
A former teacher may be excellent at training and relationship building. That doesn’t automatically mean they can forecast renewals, manage a revenue portfolio or analyse customer data.
A Customer Success Manager from another SaaS sector may be a strong fit when they have managed similar customers, contract values and levels of complexity.
Assess whether they have worked with:
Relevant experience matters more than a perfect sector label.
A book of business matters less in customer success than it may in sales.
The person will usually be managing customers the company has already won.
A network may help them understand the market and build credibility, but they shouldn’t be offering to move customers from a former employer.
Ask about the portfolio they managed rather than requesting customer names.
Useful questions include:
A candidate who managed 200 simple accounts may not be ready to manage ten complex university partnerships.
Someone who managed five large enterprise accounts may struggle in a role that requires a more scaled approach.
Portfolio relevance matters more than the logos on their CV.
Customer success salaries vary widely because the same title can cover support, implementation, account management and commercial ownership.
As a broad UK planning guide:
Around £35,000 to £45,000.
This person may support onboarding, training, product questions and smaller accounts.
Around £45,000 to £60,000.
This may suit someone managing their own customer portfolio, product adoption and renewal activity.
Around £60,000 to £85,000 or more.
This person may manage strategic customers, senior relationships, complex implementations and commercial renewals.
The revenue leader should consider:
Someone managing several million pounds in renewable revenue shouldn’t be paid like a customer support adviser.
A bonus can make sense when the person influences renewals, retention or expansion.
But don’t give them targets for outcomes they can’t control.
Pricing, product quality, sales promises and contract negotiations may sit with other teams.
Possible measures include:
Use a balanced set of measures.
A Customer Success Manager shouldn’t feel pressure to hide product issues or unhappy customers because their entire bonus depends on a customer satisfaction score.
A specialist Customer Success Manager search can take several months from defining the role to having the person fully managing customers.
A sensible plan is:
The person shouldn’t be expected to understand the product, rebuild onboarding, learn every account and reduce churn during their first month.
You should still see early progress.
They should begin identifying customer risks, improving records and building clearer plans within the first few months.
The best candidate may not currently have the exact title you are advertising.
Consider people working as:
Use several search routes.
Map companies that sell to similar customers and use a similar customer model.
Ask sales leaders, revenue leaders, customers and founders which Customer Success Managers they rate and why.
Education and customer success communities can help you reach people who aren’t actively applying.
Search by customer type, contract value, onboarding responsibility and renewal ownership rather than relying only on job titles.
A specialist recruiter should help the hiring leader decide whether the company needs customer success, implementation, support or account management before beginning the search.
Customer success interviews can focus too heavily on personality.
Being warm and easy to speak to helps.
It isn’t enough.
Ask candidates for evidence from recent roles:
Look for clear answers and personal ownership.
Be cautious when every success belongs to the candidate but every lost customer is blamed on sales, product or pricing.
Those factors may have played a part.
A strong candidate can still explain what they did, what they learnt and what they would do differently.
Give shortlisted candidates a short customer scenario.
For example:
A multi academy trust bought your platform six months ago. Ten schools were expected to use it, but only three are active. The original sponsor has left. Renewal is due in four months.
Ask the candidate to explain:
You could also ask them to run part of a customer review meeting.
Keep the task short.
You are assessing how they think, ask questions and create a practical plan.
Speak with former managers where possible.
Ask:
Someone may perform well in a large company with onboarding teams, support specialists, analysts and renewal managers.
Your first Customer Success Manager may have far less support.
The line manager plays a central role.
The Customer Success Manager needs clear goals, access to information and regular coaching.
Before the person starts, prepare:
Every new customer should have a proper handover from sales.
The Customer Success Manager needs to know:
A CRM note saying “great client, keen to start” isn’t a handover.
The revenue leader shouldn’t assume that hiring a Customer Success Manager means the customer base can now run without oversight.
Useful management may include:
The manager should challenge weak thinking without taking over every account.
The goal is to give the Customer Success Manager ownership while making sure serious risks receive the right level of support.
Account numbers alone don’t show whether a portfolio is realistic.
Ten enterprise customers with complex integrations may require more work than 100 smaller customers using a simple product.
Consider:
Don’t ask someone to build strategic relationships while giving them so many accounts that every conversation becomes reactive.
Revenue retention matters, but some renewal outcomes may relate to decisions made before the person joined.
Track early signs of progress:
Measure the person on what they could reasonably influence during the period.
A good Customer Success Manager:
The revenue team should have better visibility after they join.
There should be fewer surprises.
The CRO or Sales Director shouldn’t discover that a major customer is leaving two weeks before the renewal date.
Be cautious when a Customer Success Manager:
Happy conversations don’t always lead to successful customers.
The Customer Success Manager can improve the customer journey.
They can’t compensate indefinitely for a poor product, weak implementation or unrealistic sales promises.
The revenue leader should make sure the whole commercial team shares responsibility for the customer experience.
Sales should set honest expectations.
Customer success should drive outcomes and identify risks.
Product and support should respond to recurring problems.
Leadership should act when the evidence shows that something needs to change.
The goal is to hire someone who helps customers achieve meaningful outcomes while protecting recurring revenue.
That requires sector understanding, commercial judgement, clear communication and the ability to build a process.
The revenue leader needs to define the role, provide regular support and measure both customer progress and business results.
A strong Customer Success Manager should improve retention, create more predictable revenue and give customers greater confidence in their decision to work with you.
RecruitHer helps EdTech companies hire Customer Success, Implementation, Account Management and go to market professionals. We assess candidates against the customers, portfolio and commercial work they will actually manage, rather than relying only on titles, sector names or personality.
Don’t hire one simply because the sales team is too busy to answer customer questions. Customer success is not a more polished name for customer support. Before recruiting, you should be able to explain what outcome customers are buying, what successful product use looks like, why customers renew or leave, and who owns onboarding, training, support, renewals and expansion.
The role may report to a Head of Customer Success, CRO, Sales Director, VP Sales, Head of Revenue, Chief Customer Officer or COO. The reporting line should reflect what the person is expected to own, and their targets should match it. For example, they shouldn’t be told customer outcomes are the priority while being measured only on expansion revenue.
Look for the ability to understand customer outcomes, manage onboarding, drive adoption, work with several stakeholders, run useful customer meetings, spot risk early, set expectations, think commercially, represent the customer internally and build a process. Warmth and organisation help, but they are not enough on their own.
It can be a major advantage because the person may already understand budget cycles, procurement and how schools or universities work. But sector knowledge shouldn’t replace customer success skills. A candidate from another SaaS sector may be a strong fit if they have managed similar customers, contract values and complexity, because relevant experience matters more than a perfect sector label.
As a broad UK planning guide, a Customer Success Associate or Executive is around £35,000 to £45,000, a Customer Success Manager around £45,000 to £60,000, and a senior or enterprise Customer Success Manager around £60,000 to £85,000 or more. The right figure depends on portfolio value, customer complexity, renewal ownership and seniority.
A specialist search can take several months from defining the role to having the person fully managing customers. A sensible plan is one to two weeks to define the role and scorecard, four to eight weeks for sourcing and interviews, time for the offer and notice period, and several weeks of product and customer training.
RecruitHer helps EdTech companies hire Customer Success, Implementation, Account Management and go to market professionals. If you would like to talk through the role, the scorecard or your search, book a 10-minute call or find out how RecruitHer works with EdTech companies.
Emilia Kruszewska is the founder and CEO of RecruitHer, a specialist recruitment and career strategy business for the education and EdTech sector. A former educator and EdTech sales leader, she built and ran her own education business for seven years before selling it to a competitor. Today she partners with founders and hiring managers to build high impact EdTech teams, and helps educators and EdTech professionals position their experience for their next move. You can connect with Emilia on LinkedIn.
